6.0 Refinement of the Self-Evaluation and Planning Guide
The development of the self-evaluation and planning guide was a cornerstone of the weather information integration project. The Guide, as described in the previous sections, is a standalone Microsoft Access database application with a companion written document version. This section provides feedback from the TMCs on the Guide and presents options for further refinement and updates of the Guide.
6.1 Feedback and Changes Suggested by Users of the Guide
The TMC representatives who participated in this project appreciated the thoroughness of the Guide content, clarity of instructions, and the applicability of the integration strategies presented. Specific feedback was requested and obtained based on the use of the electronic version of the tool. The Guide was updated and improved based on the suggestions from the users. Table 22 provides a tabular summary of the changes requested by the TMCs and the changes implemented in the Guide.
Reason for Suggested Change to the Guide |
Description of Change Implemented |
---|---|
Need header and footer in reports that users can print out based on user inputs. This will help when TMCs are printing multiple Guide section reports for multiple regions (such as in Louisiana) or having individuals fill out the Guide separately and then print it. |
Added a form at the beginning of the Guide to allow users to enter the following:
|
Need additional sections in the Guide after Section 6. Currently, the TMCs get through the self-evaluation process and find themselves overwhelmed by the number of strategies presented to them. Need a structure that allows TMCs to further prioritize and narrow the set of strategies that they want to carry forward. |
|
Comment in Section 1: |
|
Comment from a TMC in Section 2 (Question 2.1): |
|
Comment in Section 3: |
|
Comments on Reports: |
|
Comments on Section 7: |
|
Editorial: |
|
The Guide was updated in June 2010 with the changes as indicated in the table above. The corresponding document version of the Guide was likewise updated. No further changes have been suggested by the TMC users.
6.2 Updating the Guide
The self-evaluation Guide has been successfully used at all the TMCs participating in this study. For an ad-hoc electronic tool designed on the fly to support the complexities of weather integration, the Guide has held up remarkably well to the variety of TMCs and their varying needs. However, it is important to realize that the Guide needs to be continuously updated as the field of weather information evolves, new technologies are developed to support weather integration, and TMCs expand their needs and vision of how to more effectively integrate weather information into their daily operations.
Technically, the Guide needs a periodic update of the Weather Information Integration Strategies and User Needs. Currently, there are 11 items of integration and 5 levels for each item. These were developed to cover the gamut of information integration options in 2008. With improving technologies and capabilities within TMCs, these strategies need to be reviewed and updated. Similarly, the user needs should be reviewed and updated to reflect the current desires of TMCs.
From a usability standpoint, major additional improvements to the Guide are limited by Microsoft Access’ capabilities. TMCs have requested several usability updates that are better suited to other platforms than Microsoft Access. For example, the following suggestions identified by the TMCs would be useful but either too costly or not possible to implement in Microsoft Access:
- Translating the stand-alone application to a web-based tool will greatly enhance ease of access and repeated use of the Guide.
- Enhanced querying and what-if capabilities to understand the implications of implementing a particular user need
- Enhanced reporting capabilities, including creating reports in Microsoft Word
- Linkages to other RWMP programs and projects